Friday, October 4, 2013

Sola Scriptura debate vs Brenda Johnson show notes

John's three minute introduction
 Hello to all of you listening tonight. My name is John Benko and I am the founder of this little apostolate known as Deeper Truth Blog. Along with my wife and my friends Donald Hartley, Christie Martin, Margie Prox Sindelar, Ross Earl Hoffman and Dr. Gregory Thompson, we try to spread the good news of Jesus Christ and His Catholic church as best we can.

As for myself, I am married, almost 28 years with 3 adult children and one that is with Our Lord. I am a Chief Commercial Building Engineer and a small business owner making websites. The truth is that I am not much different from all of you.

This little blog and radio show are about 4 years old now and we are humbled that you are tuning in.

Our Blog is at deepertruthblog.com and our radio show, twitter, several facebook accounts and lots of other stuff can be found there as well as links to some of our best of shows and articles.

Opposition to the man-made doctrine of Sola Scriptura is not an assault on Scripture, let's get that straight, right out of the gate. In fact, the reverse is true- While orthodox Christianity affirms the actual infallible content of Scripture, proponents of Sola Scriptura assert that they are their own translators, their own guardians, their own interpreters, free to do with Scripture whatever they choose.

For example, tonight, my opponent will imply that only Scripture can be referred to as the Word of God, when the very words of scripture refute this equivocation;

1 Thessalonians 2:13: And we also thank God constantly for this, that when you received the word of God which you heard from us, you accepted it not as the word of men but as what it really is, the word of God, which is at work in you believers.
She will also falsely assert that Catholics add to, subtract from, and nullify the Word of God by man-made traditions. In this case, She will be falsely equivocating the definition of tradition as well.

2 Thessalonians 2: 15: So then, brethren, stand firm and hold to the traditions which you were taught by us, either by word of mouth or by letter.

She seeks to debate whether truth is expressed through the Church or through the Scriptures- a false dichotomy. The reality is that it is both- The first as witness, the second as testimony. Let's make no mistake about which came first. Those two letters to the church at Thessalonica were written well before the Gospels and before 10 of the first 11 New Testament books. The Church's teaching authority was well established long before the Bible even started to take form.

But Brenda asserts, in her own words, that the Scriptures themselves "... are the supreme and final authority in faith and life".  The authority means one authority. It is a declarative, exclusionary statement that says that scripture is the one and only authority and the doctrine of Sola Scriptura, by definition, echoes this claim. She bears the burden of proof to affirm this ridiculous assertion.

au·thor·i·ty

 1. rule, power, sway. Authority, control, influence denote a power or right to direct the actions or thoughts of others. Authority is a power or right, usually because of rank or office, to issue commands and to punish for violations: to have authority over subordinates.
Authority, by definition, is something always reserved for persons, never objects. It is something that is exercised.. It gives orders and it administers consequences for disobedience. Scripture cannot do this. The logical end of her ideology is impossible, a personified, living Bible. The Bible cannot be an authority because it is not a person, it is an object. Printed words, on a page, cannot argue, interpret or explain themselves, they can only be argued, be interpreted and be explained by men. When artifacts are asserted to have human, or even Divine, attributes, they become idols.

In Acts 8:31, the Eunuch asked, with regard to understanding Scripture, "How can I unless someone explains it to me?' Sola Scriptura would stipulate that Isaiah's writings would explain themselves to the Eunuch. The corollary end of Sola Scriptura is to attribute nothing less than Divine action to an inanimate object. Well, how is that working for ya and your 42,000 protestant denominations?

When arguing whether the church must interpret the Bible or the Bible must interpret the church, logic dictates that that the one that is actually alive is better suited for the task. Does the author explain the Book or does the book explain the author? Matthew 18:15-18 affirms this in no uncertain terms. In a dispute, Jesus instructs that the Church is the final authority. That is what makes Sola Scriptura so ironic because Scripture always makes this case.

The Bible is a collection of books inspired by God but written by men. The books are organized by genre, not chronologically. 46 Old Testament Books, 27 New Testament. 73 Books in all. That is the form and substance of the first Bible, the Latin Vulgate, which was commissioned by Pope Damasus I in 382 AD and finished before his death in 384.

There were 38 Popes by the time that first completed Bible was finished. in fact, we were already up to our 4th (Pope Clement) before the last books would even be written that would make it into the canon.The historical record is clear. The Catholic church preceded the Bible by centuries, making Sola Scriptura a historical impossibility. Protestant soteriology demands that we pretend the Bible fell from the sky.

We agree that the original Scriptures are free from error. Protestant translations are another matter. They are loaded with errors. One example is the NIV which inserts the word mother into the passage of Luke 11:27-28 when the Greek word for mother is wholly absent from the text. Here, The NIV adds to the Word of God.  In Luke 1:28, the KJV reduces Kecharitomene which means "endured with perfected Grace", to "favor". The KJV is subtracting from the Word of God.

It comes right back to the issue of authority. It is ironic that the first English protestant Bible was actually called the Authorized King James version. King James was an English monarch, with no more sanction to Authorize a Bible translation than Barack Obama. Of course, if you believe in the KJV, you have to believe in unicorns! (Numbers 24:8)

My opponent asserts that the scriptures need no authority to safeguard them but that is utter nonsense! Of course they do! If God says "Wild Ox" or "Rhinoceros" but man translates 'Unicorn', it is no longer God's word but man's word. This is where 'Scripture alone' goes off the rails.  If you cannot even agree on what is Scripture, or what it says, how can you make it an authority!?

The truth is that catholics believe in and affirm the scriptures precisely because we can trust the Authority that safeguards them.  Jesus said of that church "He who hears you, hears me. he who rejects you, rejects me. He who rejects me rejects Him who sent me" ( Luke 10:16 ) and "If He will not listen even to the church, treat him as an unbeliever. What you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, what you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven" ( Matthew 18:18 )

The term church appears 112 times in the New Testament including in 1 Timothy 3:15 where she is called the pillar and foundation of all truth and we are reminded how to act when we are in her. This obliterates the invisible church, Bible-alone ideology that props up Protestantism  The church is visible and speaks with God's authority. Scripture is just one manifestation of that.

Brenda claims that she believes the Bible but the Bible itself records that she is to be treated as an unbeliever because she refuses to hear or listen to the church or be bound on earth to what is bound in heaven. When what we disagree upon is the proper interpretation of Scripture, Jesus told us who has the authority to settle the matter.

The Catholic church was preaching and teaching Christ crucified more than 350 years before the first Bible and almost 1500 years before the first protestant. To suggest that Martin Luther is a model of what Christ's infant church looked like is preposterous. Brenda does not dare make an appeal to the historical record to support such nonsense. So, when you hear Brenda exclaim "The Bible alone! The Bible alone!", what she is really revealing is a dread fear of unimpeachable history.

Matthew 21:43 put Israel on notice that their authority would be stripped but God made no such claim about His Catholic church. In fact, He said the gates of hell would not prevail against it. Martin Luther came in his own name, not in God's and the baggage that he brought does not bear God's sanction.

A proper Scriptural hermeneutic requires sober reflection on literary, linguistic, liturgical and cultural context. It is a daunting task and the church is empowered to do so. Private interpretation has never been sanctioned and the notion of Scriptural perspicuity could not be more alien to the biblical text. Peter said it best-

2 Peter 1:20: First of all you must understand this, that no prophecy of scripture is a matter of one's own interpretation,

and

2 Peter 3: 16: speaking of this as he (Paul) does in all his letters. There are some things in them hard to understand, which the ignorant and unstable twist to their own destruction, as they do the other scriptures.

Sola Scriptura collapses under it's own weight when we get to specifics. Non-catholics cannot agree on the Trinity, the Priesthood or Bishops, the Real presence, the day of worship, Baptism, how we are saved, Dispensationalism, Zionism, the rapture or anything else the Bible contains or is alleged to contain. Yet they all claim to follow the Bible alone when none of them actually do. They all believe what their pastors tell them to believe. 


Sola Scriptura doesn't defend Scripture but the right to abuse Scripture and to make it one's personal play thing. Brenda seeks to take her novel, man-made, 19th and 20th century doctrines and bend and twist scripture to fit these new schemes. Talk about adding to God's Word! Talk about man-made traditions! Virtually everything Brenda believes is man-made tradition that is added to God's word! I, on the other hand, hold fast to what the true church has always found in Scripture and taught from Scripture.

The clear testimony of the early church damns her belief system. Show me a 1st, 2nd or 3rd century church that proclaimed a rapture. You can't! it was invented in the 1800s. Born-Againism came out of the 1970s! Sola Scriptura is a little older but not much, not by historical standards. If Sola Scriptura is so foundational, why is not even mentioned in the first 15 centuries of the church? Not a syllable! There is not a syllable in Scripture itself to support it either and she knows it.

Catholics on the other hand can appeal to the clear historical record to show that what we believe now, is what they believed then. In 110 AD, Ignatius, a disciple of John, said

 Wherever the bishop shall appear, there let the multitude[of the people] also be; even as, wherever Jesus Christ is, there is the Catholic Church. 
In fact, the exact same phrase that Ignatius uses, Ecclesia Kath Olos, is actually present in the Greek text of Acts 9:31 which means that even the Bible alone testifies for the Catholic Church

Even Martin Luther himself, in his introduction to his commentary on the Gospel of John said
"We are compelled to concede to the Papists that they have the Word of GOD, that we received it from them, and that without them, we should have no knowledge of it at all."


Indeed.
These are some of the arguments I feel Brenda is likely to raise and my counters to them.

1) The Word of God. 

This often includes the admonition to not "add to, subtract from or nullify" the Word of God. What it amounts to is known as an existential fallacy, where a broad concept's definition is applied to only one of it's possible definitions. True, Scripture, properly translated is called the Word of God. However, that word has always pointed to authority.


Deuteronomy 21:5 And the priests the sons of Levi shall come near; for them the Lord thy God hath chosen to minister unto him, and to bless in the name of the Lord; and by their word shall every controversy and every stroke be tried:
Matthew 18:15-18
15 Moreover if thy brother shall trespass against thee, go and tell him his fault between thee and him alone: if he shall hear thee, thou hast gained thy brother.16 But if he will not hear thee, then take with thee one or two more, that in the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established.17 And if he shall neglect to hear them, tell it unto the church: but if he neglect to hear the church, let him be unto thee as an heathen man and a publican.18 Verily I say unto you, Whatsoever ye shall bind on earth shall be bound in heaven: and whatsoever ye shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven. 
In 1 Kings 12 and 13, we see that the Word of God is spoken, In Jeremiah 5:14, God says that his Word will proceed from Jeremiah's mouth, in Luke 3:2, we are told that the Word of God came to John the Baptist, in Luke 11:28, Jesus blesses those who hear the Word of God, in John 1, Jesus, Himself, is called the Word of God, in Acts 10:36, we see the Word of God was sent by preaching, in Acts 13:46, the Word of God is spoken to us, in Hebrews 10:16, the Word of God is placed in our hearts and minds. I could give countless examples. The bottom line is that Jesus said of His church, "He who hears you, hears me". Do not add to, subtract from or nullify the Word of God refers to the Word of God- however it is transmitted.

2) Acts says that the Beareans were noble minded and searched the Scriptures to see if these things were true.

The Beareans did search the scriptures diligently but they did not only search them. Acts says they received the word and searched the Scriptures. They verified Paul's oral teaching. Notice they did not conclude what Paul taught by means of scripture alone.

Luke starts his other letter acknowledging that the faithful have already received the teachings of Christ, and is writing his Gospel only so that they "realize the certainty of the teachings you have received." Luke writes to verify the oral tradition they already received.

3) "Do not go beyond what is written"

With regard to Paul's admonition not to go beyond the written word, in 1 Corinthians 4:6-7, a more
precise translation is do not go beyond the line. However, even if we concede the former, context,
 once again obliterates the protestant assertion, for if you drop down only 7 lines, you see Paul
 reassert His own authority and that of Timothy. He even calls himself a father, obliterating the false canard
 based on Matthew 23:9;

14 I do not write this to make you ashamed, but to admonish you as my beloved children.15 For though you have countless guides in Christ, you do not have many fathers. For I became your father in Christ Jesus through the gospel. 16 I urge you, then, be imitators of me. 17 Therefore I sent[a] to you Timothy, my beloved and faithful child in the Lord, to remind you of my ways in Christ, as I teach them everywhere in every church. 18 Some are arrogant, as though I were not coming to you. 19 But I will come to you soon, if the Lord wills, and I will find out not the talk of these arrogant people but their power.20 For the kingdom of God does not consist in talk but in power. 21 What do you wish? Shall I come to you with a rod, or with love in a spirit of gentleness?

1 Thess. 3:10 - Paul wants to see the Thessalonians face to face and supply what is lacking. His letter is not enough.

Paul is the authority, not his letters.


4) 2 Timothy 3:16-17

2 Timothy 3:16-17 says that Scripture is useful and profitable. It does not say, or even imply, that it is sufficient. In fact, if you back up only two verses, the context proves just the opposite because Paul instructs Timothy to remember what he learned and who he learned it from and to hold fast to the scriptures. Paul is explicitly affirming both the authoritativeness of Scripture and the authority of the church here, refuting, not supporting Brenda's arguments. Further, man of God
(Theos and anthropos) refers to clergy and this also supports authority.

To further hammer this home,
James 1:4 - steadfastness also makes a man "perfect (teleioi) and complete (holoklepoi), lacking nothing." This verse is important because "teleioi"and "holoklepoi" are much stronger words than "artios," but Protestants do not argue that steadfastness is all one needs to be a Christian.
Titus 3:8 - good deeds are also "profitable" to men. For Protestants especially, profitable cannot mean "exclusive" here.
2 Tim 2:21- purity is also profitable for "any good work" ("pan ergon agathon"). This wording is the same as 2 Tim. 3:17, which shows that the Scriptures are not exclusive, and that other things (good deeds and purity) are also profitable to men.
Col. 4:12 - prayer also makes men "fully assured." No where does Scripture say the Christian faith is based solely on a book.
2 Tim. 3:16-17 - Finally, if these verses really mean that Paul was teaching sola Scriptura to the early Church, then why in 1 Thess. 2:13 does Paul teach that he is giving Revelation from God orally? Either Paul is contradicting his own teaching on sola Scriptura, or Paul was not teaching sola Scriptura in 2 Tim. 3:16-17. This is a critical point which Protestants cannot reconcile with their sola Scriptura position.
(Thanks to John Salza at Scripture catholic)

In 2:2 he says:

2 Timothy 2:2

Revised Standard Version (RSV)
2 and what you have heard from me before many witnesses entrust to faithful men who will be able to teach others also.

5) You have so soon forsaken the gospel


Galatians 1;
6 I wonder that you are so soon removed from him that called you into the grace of Christ, unto another gospel. 7 Which is not another, only there are some that trouble you, and would pervert the gospel of Christ.8 But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach a gospel to you besides that which we have preached to you, let him be anathema.9 As we said before, so now I say again: If any one preach to you a gospel, besides that which you have received, let him be anathema.

Notice that Paul says that the Gospel has been preached to you, not written to you. Paul is
upholding the Church's authority and not just defending Scripture. Indeed, when Paul wrote
 those words to the Galatians, it was one of the first 3 New Testament books to be written
 and it definitely preceded all 4 Gospels. So, Paul was preaching to a church that only knew the

 Gospel by oral tradition.

6) The Scripture cannot be broken (John 10:35) 
Once again, this verse does not get Protestants where they want to go. Jesus is simply saying that the Scripture cannot be violated, that is, "broken". He is not saying that Scripture is the only means by which He communicates. In fact, in verse 38, He states that the mighty works He does is one means by which we can believe. That is true even today, miracles occur in the Catholic church.

7) John 20:31 But these are written, that ye might believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God; and that believing ye might have life through his name.

Once again, this does not prove exclusivity.
 Romans 10:14

How then shall they call on him in whom they have not believed? and how shall they believe in him of whom they have not heard? and how shall they hear without a preacher?

Mark 16:15 - Jesus commands the apostles to "preach," not write, and only three apostles wrote. The others who did not write were not less faithful to Jesus, because Jesus gave them no directive to write. There is no evidence in the Bible or elsewhere that Jesus intended the Bible to be sole authority of the Christian faith.

8) The Apocrypha

We have a link to an article  far too exhaustive in it's research to introduce here that shows factually, that where the Septuagint differs from the Masoretic text, the Septuagint is preferred overwhelming in New Testament quotes of the old testament. You can find that link in our show notes under rebuttal points.  In the case of each NT book, the percentage of agreement varies from 86.9-100% with the Septuagint.

As for the contention that none of the Deuterocanonicals are quoted in the New Testament, 
Matt. 2:16 - Herod's decree of slaying innocent children was prophesied in Wis. 11:7 - slaying the holy innocents.
Matt. 6:19-20 - Jesus' statement about laying up for yourselves treasure in heaven follows Sirach 29:11 - lay up your treasure.
Matt.. 7:12 - Jesus' golden rule "do unto others" is the converse of Tobit 4:15 - what you hate, do not do to others.
Matt. 7:16,20 - Jesus' statement "you will know them by their fruits" follows Sirach 27:6 - the fruit discloses the cultivation.
Matt. 9:36 - the people were "like sheep without a shepherd" is same as Judith 11:19 - sheep without a shepherd.
Matt. 11:25 - Jesus' description "Lord of heaven and earth" is the same as Tobit 7:18 - Lord of heaven and earth.
Matt. 12:42 - Jesus refers to the wisdom of Solomon which was recorded and made part of the deuterocanonical books.
Matt. 16:18 - Jesus' reference to the "power of death" and "gates of Hades" references Wisdom 16:13.
Matt. 22:25; Mark 12:20; Luke 20:29 - Gospel writers refer to the canonicity of Tobit 3:8 and 7:11 regarding the seven brothers.
Matt. 24:15 - the "desolating sacrilege" Jesus refers to is also taken from 1 Macc. 1:54 and 2 Macc. 8:17.
Matt. 24:16 - let those "flee to the mountains" is taken from 1 Macc. 2:28.
Matt. 27:43 - if He is God's Son, let God deliver him from His adversaries follows Wisdom 2:18.
Mark 4:5,16-17 - Jesus' description of seeds falling on rocky ground and having no root follows Sirach 40:15.
Mark 9:48 - description of hell where their worm does not die and the fire is not quenched references Judith 16:17.
Luke 1:42 - Elizabeth's declaration of Mary's blessedness above all women follows Uzziah's declaration in Judith 13:18.
Luke 1:52 - Mary's magnificat addressing the mighty falling from their thrones and replaced by lowly follows Sirach 10:14.
Luke 2:29 - Simeon's declaration that he is ready to die after seeing the Child Jesus follows Tobit 11:9.
Luke 13:29 - the Lord's description of men coming from east and west to rejoice in God follows Baruch 4:37.
Luke 21:24 - Jesus' usage of "fall by the edge of the sword" follows Sirach 28:18.
Luke 24:4 and Acts 1:10 - Luke's description of the two men in dazzling apparel reminds us of 2 Macc. 3:26.
John 1:3 - all things were made through Him, the Word, follows Wisdom 9:1.
John 3:13 - who has ascended into heaven but He who descended from heaven references Baruch 3:29.
John 4:48; Acts 5:12; 15:12; 2 Cor. 12:12 - Jesus', Luke's and Paul's usage of "signs and wonders" follows Wisdom 8:8.
John 5:18 - Jesus claiming that God is His Father follows Wisdom 2:16.
John 6:35-59 - Jesus' Eucharistic discourse is foreshadowed in Sirach 24:21.
John 10:22 - the identification of the feast of the dedication is taken from 1 Macc. 4:59.
John 10:36 – Jesus accepts the inspiration of Maccabees as He analogizes the Hanukkah consecration to His own consecration to the Father in 1 Macc. 4:36.
John 15:6 - branches that don't bear fruit and are cut down follows Wis. 4:5 where branches are broken off.
Acts 1:15 - Luke's reference to the 120 may be a reference to 1 Macc. 3:55 - leaders of tens / restoration of the twelve.
Acts 10:34; Rom. 2:11; Gal. 2:6 - Peter's and Paul's statement that God shows no partiality references Sirach 35:12.
Acts 17:29 - description of false gods as like gold and silver made by men follows Wisdom 13:10.
Rom 1:18-25 - Paul's teaching on the knowledge of the Creator and the ignorance and sin of idolatry follows Wis. 13:1-10.
Rom. 1:20 - specifically, God's existence being evident in nature follows Wis. 13:1.
Rom. 1:23 - the sin of worshipping mortal man, birds, animals and reptiles follows Wis. 11:15; 12:24-27; 13:10; 14:8.
Rom. 1:24-27 - this idolatry results in all kinds of sexual perversion which follows Wis. 14:12,24-27.
Rom. 4:17 - Abraham is a father of many nations follows Sirach 44:19.
Rom. 5:12 - description of death and sin entering into the world is similar to Wisdom 2:24.
Rom. 9:21 - usage of the potter and the clay, making two kinds of vessels follows Wisdom 15:7.
1 Cor. 2:16 - Paul's question, "who has known the mind of the Lord?" references Wisdom 9:13.
1 Cor. 6:12-13; 10:23-26 - warning that, while all things are good, beware of gluttony, follows Sirach 36:18 and 37:28-30.
1 Cor. 8:5-6 - Paul acknowledging many "gods" but one Lord follows Wis. 13:3.
1 Cor. 10:1 - Paul's description of our fathers being under the cloud passing through the sea refers to Wisdom 19:7.
1 Cor. 10:20 - what pagans sacrifice they offer to demons and not to God refers to Baruch 4:7.
1 Cor. 15:29 - if no expectation of resurrection, it would be foolish to be baptized on their behalf follows 2 Macc. 12:43-45.
Eph. 1:17 - Paul's prayer for a "spirit of wisdom" follows the prayer for the spirit of wisdom in Wisdom 7:7.
Eph. 6:14 - Paul describing the breastplate of righteousness is the same as Wis. 5:18. See also Isaiah 59:17 and 1 Thess. 5:8.
Eph. 6:13-17 - in fact, the whole discussion of armor, helmet, breastplate, sword, shield follows Wis. 5:17-20.
1 Tim. 6:15 - Paul's description of God as Sovereign and King of kings is from 2 Macc. 12:15; 13:4.
2 Tim. 4:8 - Paul's description of a crown of righteousness is similar to Wisdom 5:16.
Heb. 4:12 - Paul's description of God's word as a sword is similar to Wisdom 18:15.
Heb. 11:5 - Enoch being taken up is also referenced in Wis 4:10 and Sir 44:16. See also 2 Kings 2:1-13 & Sir 48:9 regarding Elijah.
Heb 11:35 - Paul teaches about the martyrdom of the mother and her sons described in 2 Macc. 7:1-42.
Heb. 12:12 - the description "drooping hands" and "weak knees" comes from Sirach 25:23.
James 1:19 - let every man be quick to hear and slow to respond follows Sirach 5:11.
James 2:23 - it was reckoned to him as righteousness follows 1 Macc. 2:52 - it was reckoned to him as righteousness.
James 3:13 - James' instruction to perform works in meekness follows Sirach 3:17.
James 5:3 - describing silver which rusts and laying up treasure follows Sirach 29:10-11.
James 5:6 - condemning and killing the "righteous man" follows Wisdom 2:10-20.
1 Peter 1:6-7 - Peter teaches about testing faith by purgatorial fire as described in Wisdom 3:5-6 and Sirach 2:5.
1 Peter 1:17 - God judging each one according to his deeds refers to Sirach 16:12 - God judges man according to his deeds.
2 Peter 2:7 - God's rescue of a righteous man (Lot) is also described in Wisdom 10:6.
Rev. 1:4 – the seven spirits who are before his throne is taken from Tobit 12:15 – Raphael is one of the seven holy angels who present the prayers of the saints before the Holy One.
Rev. 1:18; Matt. 16:18 - power of life over death and gates of Hades follows Wis. 16:13.
Rev. 2:12 - reference to the two-edged sword is similar to the description of God's Word in Wisdom 18:16.
Rev. 5:7 - God is described as seated on His throne, and this is the same description used in Sirach 1:8.
Rev. 8:3-4 - prayers of the saints presented to God by the hand of an angel follows Tobit 12:12,15.
Rev. 8:7 - raining of hail and fire to the earth follows Wisdom 16:22 and Sirach 39:29.
Rev. 9:3 - raining of locusts on the earth follows Wisdom 16:9.
Rev. 11:19 - the vision of the ark of the covenant (Mary) in a cloud of glory was prophesied in 2 Macc. 2:7.
Rev. 17:14 - description of God as King of kings follows 2 Macc. 13:4.
Rev. 19:1 - the cry "Hallelujah" at the coming of the new Jerusalem follows Tobit 13:18.
Rev. 19:11 - the description of the Lord on a white horse in the heavens follows 2 Macc. 3:25; 11:8.
Rev. 19:16 - description of our Lord as King of kings is taken from 2 Macc. 13:4.
Rev. 21:19 - the description of the new Jerusalem with precious stones is prophesied in Tobit 13:17.
Exodus 23:7 - do not slay the innocent and righteous - Dan. 13:53 - do not put to death an innocent and righteous person.
1 Sam. 28:7-20 – the intercessory mediation of deceased Samuel for Saul follows Sirach 46:20.
2 Kings 2:1-13 – Elijah being taken up into heaven follows Sirach 48:9.
2 Tim. 3:16 - the inspired Scripture that Paul was referring to included the deuterocanonical texts that the Protestants removed. The books Baruch, Tobit, Maccabees, Judith, Sirach, Wisdom and parts of Daniel and Esther were all included in the Septuagint that Jesus and the apostles used.
Sirach and 2 Maccabees – some Protestants argue these books are not inspired because the writers express uncertainty about their abilities. But sacred writers are often humble about their divinely inspired writings. See, for example, 1 Cor. 7:40 – Paul says he “thinks” that he has the Spirit of God.
The Protestants attempt to defend their rejection of the deuterocanonicals on the ground that the early Jews rejected them. However, the Jewish councils that rejected them (e.g., School of Javneh (also called “Jamnia” in 90 - 100 A.D.) were the same councils that rejected the entire New Testatment canon. Thus, Protestants who reject the Catholic Bible are following a Jewish council that rejected Christ and the Revelation of the New Testament.

Thank you, Scripture Catholic.com

 1) Brenda, making an appeal to Scripture alone, can you please show me how I can know what the Books of the Bible are and in what order they should go?

2) In Acts 15, Peter solved the first recorded Church dispute without an appeal to Scripture. Please explain how this is possible with Sola Scriptura.

3) In Acts 8, why did the Eunuch say he could not possibly understand the Scriptures unless someone explained them to Him?

4) Can you interpret Scripture infallibly? If not, can you tell me what Scriptures you interpret incorrectly?

John 21:25 tells us the whole world could not contain enough books to record all the things Jesus did. John chapter 1 tells us that Jesus does not merely bring the Word of God or proclaim the Word of God, He IS The Word of God. Well, Jesus isn't a book!...and He isn't confined to a book either. Jesus promised to send the Holy Spirit to the church and He, not Scripture alone, would lead the church to all truth. In Matthew 16, Jesus tells Peter that his own revelation that Jesus was the Messiah was given to Him by God personally, Peter certainly did not deduce it from Scripture alone.

   Jesus and the Apostles did appeal to Scripture on a regular basis, who would think otherwise? They were infallible teachers. Their interpretations could be trusted infallibly. On the other hand, The Sadducees, the Judaizers and even Satan, also appealed to Scripture to support their positions and were rebuked for doing so. So, it is the correct authority that properly interprets Scripture, not Scripture itself.

If the argument is stripped of pretense and reduced to it's purest question, do Catholic or protestant views most closely conform to Scripture, it isn't even a contest. All of the Catholic doctrines are scriptural and none of the protestant ones are. The problem is that protestants view scripture through so many distorted lenses that they cannot get a true sense of what it actually says. They do not understand typology, they super-impose 21st century English language on 1st century Greek and they approach Scripture pre-disposed to make it mean what they want it to mean rather than what it actually does.  To change that, they must accept that men like Ignatius and Polycarp, who learned from the disciples, themselves, were far better positioned to know what they meant in their writings.

Let me give just one example. John chapter 3. Brenda fancies herself a "born-again" Christian. However, a born-again Christian, as she defines it, is a man-made invention not 50 years old. Even a cursory examination of early church documents proves beyond a shadow of a shadow of a doubt that the early church was unanimous in understanding being "born again" and being "born of water and spirit" to refer explicitly to Sacramental Water Baptism. (In our show notes are example quotes). Brenda belongs to an invented ideology that has nothing to do with Scripture whatsoever.

A wise man once said that if you believe only what you want from the Scriptures, it is not the scriptures you trust but yourself. When trapped by the logical consequences of this doctrine, proponents will often try to minimize what it suggests. They will deny that it makes more of Scripture than what is possible. They will falsely assert that Sola Scriptura only means that the laws of the Church cannot contradict Scripture. Of course they are being disingenuous. Sola Scriptura asserts much more than that. Sola Scriptura asserts that in the proper interpretation of scripture, there is no earthly authority except what we choose to be an authority. Thus, though we are certainly able to appeal to cultural, historical and linguistic context, we are by no means bound to. Under Sola Scriptura, we can appeal to how the early church interpreted Scripture when we think it suits us, reject it when it doesn't. Under this schema, scripture is, at once, the material to be interpreted, the means to interpret it and the binding authority to uphold that interpretation, however pernicious it may be. Though it may be true that the pen is mightier than the sword, both must be subject to he who wields them, not the other way around.

Let's review;
Proponents of Sola Scriptura claim that Scripture is the authority. Authority is something that is exercised by a person and in Scripture, itself, we read that the Church is the final authority in too many places to count. They claim Scripture interprets itself. Again, something a silent page cannot do. They claim Scripture is perspicuous, something flatly denied in Scripture (1 Peter 1:20) and proved obviously false in practice. They claim Sola Scriptura is foundational but no historical church figure can be found prior to 1517 that taught it.  They claim Scripture is formally sufficient but cannot even produce a list of canonized books or give us the authors of the Gospels without the Church's help.

G.K. Chesterson observed that it is true that we do not believe what the Scriptures say because they actually say nothing. You cannot put the Bible in the witness box and compel it to testify. That is the bottom line. The Bible cannot interpret, it can only be interpreted and none but God's ordained authority are authorized to do so. "He who hears you, hears me". That is what Jesus said to the original pastors of the church. Abraham was an authority. Moses was an authority. David was an Authority and, in Matthew 23, Jesus even said that the scribes and Pharisees were authorities because they sat in Moses' seat. Well, now, Francis sits in Peter's seat and that makes him an authority. Jesus, in Matthew 16, made Peter the authority. He called Peter the Rock, gave him the power to bind and loose and handed to him the keys to the kingdom just as foreshadowed in Isaiah 22.

Every single non-catholic denomination sect or cult, even the so-called non-denominations build their house on the same sand that is Sola Scriptura and when the wave of truth crashes in, they all fall because the very Scriptures that they purport to uphold are testimony against them.

In 2 Timothy 1:6, Paul declares to Timothy that his authority was received directly from God through Paul placing his hands on Timothy. This proves Apostolic succession and the authority of the church. That authority has been upheld and successfully defended tonight.


ADDENDUM: QUOTES ABOUT BEING "BORN-AGAIN" FROM THE EARLY CHURCH.


Justin Martyr

As many as are persuaded and believe that what we [Christians] teach and say is true, and undertake to be able to live accordingly, and instructed to pray and to entreat God with fasting, for the remission of their sins that are past, we pray and fast with them. Then they are brought by us where there is water and are regenerated in the same manner in which we were ourselves regenerated. For, in the name of God, the Father... and of our Savior Jesus Christ, and of the Holy Spirit [Matt. 28:19], they then receive the washing with water. For Christ also said, "Unless you are born again, you shall not enter into the kingdom of heaven" (First Apology 61 [A.D. 151])


Tertullian

[N]o one can attain salvation without baptism, especially in view of the declaration of the Lord, who says, "Unless a man shall be born of water, he shall not have life" (On Baptism 12:1 [A.D. 203]).


Recognitions of Clement

But you will perhaps say, 'What does the baptism of water contribute toward the worship of God?' In the first place, because that which has pleased God is fulfilled. In the second place, because when you are regenerated and born again of water and of God, the frailty of your former birth, which you have through men, is cut off, and so . . . you shall be able to attain salvation; but otherwise it is impossible. For thus has the true prophet [Jesus] testified to us with an oath: "Verily, I say to you, that unless a man is born again of water . . . he shall not enter into the kingdom of heaven" (Recognitions of Clement 6:9 [A.D. 221]).

Origen

The Church received from the apostles the tradition of giving baptism even to infants. The apostles, to whom were committed the secrets of divine sacraments, knew there is in everyone innate strains of [original] sin, which must be washed away through water and the Spirit (Commentaries on Romans 5:9 [A.D. 248]).

Cyprian

[l]t behooves those to be baptized . . . so that they are prepared, in the lawful and true and only baptism of the holy Church, by divine regeneration, for the kingdom of God . . . because it is written "Except a man be born of water and of the Spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdom of God" (Epistles 72 [73]: 21 [A.D. 252]).

Ambrose of Milan
The Church was redeemed at the price of Christ's blood. Jew or Greek, it makes no difference; but if he has believed, he must circumcise himself from his sins [in baptism (Col. 2:11-12)] so that he can be saved . . . for no one ascends into the kingdom of heaven except through the sacrament of baptism.... "Unless a man be born again of water and the Holy Spirit, he cannot enter the kingdom of God" (On Abraham 2:11:79-84 [A.D. 387]).
Augustine

It is this one Spirit who makes it possible for an infant to be regenerated . . . when that infant is brought to baptism; and it is through this one Spirit that the infant so presented is reborn. For it is not written, "Unless a man be born again by the will of his parents" or "by the faith of those presenting him or ministering to him," but, "Unless a man be born again of water and the Holy Spirit." The water, therefore, manifesting exteriorly the sacrament of grace, and the Spirit effecting interiorly the benefit of grace, both regenerate in one Christ that man who was generated in Adam (Letters 98:2 [A.D. 408]).

"Likewise it has been said: Now indeed we must treat of the divine Scriptures, what the universal Catholic Church accepts and what she ought to shun. The order of the Old Testament begins here: Genesis one book, Exodus one book, Leviticus one book, Numbers one book, Deuteronomy one book, Josue Nave one book, Judges one book, Ruth one book, Kings four books, Paralipomenon two books, Psalms one book, Solomon three books, Proverbs one book, Ecclesiastes one book, Canticle of Canticles one book, likewise Wisdom one book, Ecclesiasticus one book. Likewise the order of the Prophets. Isaias one book, Jeremias one book,with Ginoth, that is, with his lamentations, Ezechiel one book,Daniel one book, Osee one book, Micheas one book, Joel one book, Abdias one book, Jonas one book, Nahum one book, Habacuc one book, Sophonias one book, Aggeus one book, Zacharias one book, Malachias one book. Likewise the order of the histories. Job one book, Tobias one book, Esdras two books, Esther one book, Judith one book, Machabees two books. Likewise the order of the writings of the New and eternal Testament, which only the holy and Catholic Church supports. Of the Gospels, according to Matthew one book, according to Mark one book, according to Luke one book, according to John one book. The Epistles of Paul [the apostle] in number fourteen. To the Romans one, to the Corinthians two, to the Ephesians one, to the Thessalonians two, to the Galatians one, to the Philippians one, to the Colossians one, to Timothy two, to Titus one, to Philemon one, to the Hebrews one. Likewise the Apocalypse of John, one book. And the Acts of the Apostles one book. Likewise the canonical epistles in number seven. Of Peter the Apostle two epistles, of James the Apostle one epistle, of John the Apostle one epistle, of another John, the presbyter, two epistles, of Jude the Zealut, the Apostle one epistle." Pope Damasus (regn. A.D. 366-384), Decree of the Council of Rome, The Canon of Scripture (A.D. 382).

Home page
DTB facebook Page
You Tube
Blog Talk Radio Show

Bottom line: deepertruthblog is 21-0 by any objective measure.

Last night's debate was nothing if not long and grueling. In total, it ran for nearly 3 hours when you include a rather contentious question and answer session. Technical glitches dominated the opening minutes, causing me to abandon the use of Skype and the simulcast feed to Brenda's show. I will gladly, at her request, make available the MP3 download.

The debate itself.

This was the debate that never happened. As she indicated on our show, she had listened to our other Sola Scriptura debates and this clearly altered her strategy. Having heard us utterly obliterate the cases made by Sister Judy and George Lujack, She apparently realized  the futility of supporting Sola Scriptura affirmatively and abandoned any empirical case to do so.

Her entire opening statement consisted of two strategies. The first relied on anecdotal evidence of her own adolescence when, according to her, between the ages of 10 and 13, she came to read and understand Scripture in it's entirety. She continued to hold to this Scripture is easy canard and never even attempted to counter practical and Biblical arguments to the contrary.

The second part of her opening salvo was to rely liberally on the arguments of James White who defends Sola Scriptura with semantic equivocations (Sola/Solo) that directly countered Brenda's own words and the clear historical doctrine of Sola Scriptura as defined by the reformers and, frankly, insulted the intelligence of the audience.

Brenda was hoisted by her own words, in her own opening statement, that Scripture was "the only infallible source of truth" available to us. To attempt to call that characterization anything but exclusionary stretches her credibility well beyond the breaking point.

If the intention of her opening statement was merely to catch me by surprise, it succeeded. I was surprised by how effectively she pinned herself to the mat and never really attempted to get free. In her rebuttal, she created a long and interesting revisionist narrative about apostolic succession that had obviously been prescript-ed.

Rather than prepare to even attempt to counter my arguments, she simply used her rebuttal as a second opening statement. Unfortunately for her, her second opening statement, like her first, did absolutely nothing to build an affirmative case for Sola Scriptura. To compound her problem, the opening case I built against it was thorough and utterly devastating.

If there was anything that she succeeded in, it was in causing me not to present all the counter arguments I was prepared to make, simply because I couldn't mount a counter against the attack that never came. Those arguments are in our show notes.

To her credit, Brenda showed up and acted with Grace. I do not doubt that she will be far more formidable on doctrines where she is not at such a clear and overwhelming disadvantage. Last night, she lost huge but we are determined to be graceful winners and not rub salt in. We thank her for debating with us and wish her good luck in future debates.





Home page
DTB facebook Page
You Tube
Blog Talk Radio Show

Wednesday, October 2, 2013

The Catholic Defender: Hold The Line

Editors update: I just spoke with Representatives and their Staff Workers that the American people are calling in about 5 to 1 in favor of the Republicans.  Please keep the ball rolling, especially for those who are buckling.

President Obama speaking earlier today basically said that the Republicans were afraid of their Right-wing extremist...  Well, if you are a faithful follower of Jesus Christ, that makes you an "extremist"!

We are in the struggle of our lifetime.  We are sitting back and watching it unfold right before us.  If Obamacare does move forward, America will never be the same again.

We need the Republicans to hold the line and not let go because the stakes are so high.  Religious Freedom is key for all Christians.

Look at how the media is blaming the Republicans.  We need them to know that the vast majority of Americans do support them.

Look what President Obama and Senator Harry Reid have done everything to shut down the Government thinking they can get Americans to blame Republicans.  The sad thing is that the drive by media is helping the Democrats because they want to see the liberal goal go into effect.

Look at how many bills the House of Representatives have sent to the Senate? All of them paying for the requirements to pay all the bills.  They want to simply postpone Obamacare for a year which Obama himself did for his constituents and supporters.  Why can't the common man who needs the support get it just as Obama promised big business?

Just the past two days, the Democrats rejected a House bill that would open up the WWII National Monuments and other parks.

The Veterans are left depending on the support of the Republicans coming down and open up these barricades Obama had set up.

The Democrats are showing that their agenda means more to them than their listening to the American people.

The WWII Veterans who stormed Normandy and Iwo Jima were being barred from going to the monument the deserved to see.  These warriors now in their 90's many with wheel chairs, others with strollers came from Mississippi.  Obama and Reid would have left them out in the cold.  All for politics!

Obama sent more guards and support against the 90 year old WWII Veterans at the WW II Memorial than he did to help the Benghazi Embassy?

We are 17 trillion dollars in debt, 40% of every dollar is going to China.  Obamacare which is Socialized medicine that has been failing in every European Nation who has tried it.  In fact, they are trying to get out from under their health care because they are all broke and can't afford it.  We can't afford it either.

Oct 17 will begin another fight as President Obama will want the Congress to raise the debt ceiling so they can continue to tax and spend.  This is really the heart of why Senator Reid and the Democrats have not submitted a budget in the 5 years they have been the majority in the Senate.  The "CR's" are to keep the public ignorant to how much money they waste in Washington.

From Donald Trump, he sums Obamacare this way:

Let me get this straight . . ..We’re going to be “gifted” with a health care plan we are forced to purchase and fined if we don’t, Which purportedly covers at least ten million more people, without adding a single new doctor, but provides for 16,000 new IRS agents, written by a committee whose chairman says he doesn’t understand it, passed by a Congress that didn’t read it but exempted themselves from it, and signed by a Dumbo President who smokes, with funding administered by a treasury chief who didn’t pay his taxes, for which we’ll be taxed for four years before any benefits take effect, by a government which has already bankrupted Social Security and Medicare, all to be overseen by a surgeon general who is obese, and financed by a country that’s broke! ‘What the hell could possibly go wrong?’




Home page
DTB facebook Page
You Tube
Blog Talk Radio Show

Sola Scriptura debate listeners guide


Who: Brenda Johnson, protestant apologist vs John Benko, Catholic apologist, founder of Deepertruthblog
What: Debate on the Protestant doctrine of Sola Scriptura.
When: This Thursday, October 3rd, starting at 7:00 PM Eastern time.
Where: blogtalkradio.com/deeper-truth
             blogtalkradio.com/asthedayapproaches
How: Live, audio debate, on internet radio, to be moderated, scripted and archived.

All of the details have been worked out, so here are your guidelines to follow the debate.

The contestants and the moderator have agreed to the following rules; No talkover or Ad hom attacks or any other form of abusive or inappropriate language. No avoiding of direct questions. Honest effort to maintain adherence to time limits.

The best way to listen in to take your internet browser to either blogtalkradio.com/deeper-truth or blogtalkradio.com/asthedayapproaches

If you cannot listen by internet, and want to call-in to listen only (you do not wish to ask a question or make a comment), we suggest that you call (323) 410-0099. On the other hand, if you do wish to speak to the host, to ask a question or make a comment, the number to call is (646) 595-2071.

If you do call in to to talk to the show host, please do not play the show over your computer at the same time, as this will cause a feedback loop. Also, please refrain from using a speaker phone as this can cause echo.

The show will start promptly at 7:00 PM Eastern time (6:00 PM Central, 5:00 Mountain, 4:00 Pacific time). If you are unable to listen live, archive versions will be available at both sites within hours, if not less.

The formalities:

The show will start at 7:00 PM Eastern, with an introduction of the moderator. We are very pleased to have Mr. Kohl Nelson, a fine gentleman who has been agreed to by both parties because of his good nature, humility and fairness.

Mr. Nelson will introduce Mr. Donald Hartley who will be running the technical aspects of the program. Mr. Hartley will man the switchboard and soundboard and will periodically check the chat room, as well as acting in the role of timekeeper for the statements, rebuttals and questions.

Next, Mr Nelson will introduce the first contestant, Brenda Johnson, who will have up to 3 minutes to introduce herself and talk about her background.

John Benko will be given the same opportunity, next.

The Debate:

Brenda Johnson will have the floor for up to 10 minutes for an opening statement affirming the protestant doctrine of Sola Scriptura.

*Commercial break* The views expressed in our commercial breaks reflect the views of the Deeper Truth show and not necessarily those of all particular listeners, particularly those listening, by simulcast on Brenda Johnson's program.

John Benko will have up to 5 minutes to rebut Brenda Johnson's opening statement.

John Benko will then follow with his opening statement.

*Commercial break* The views expressed in our commercial breaks reflect the views of the Deeper Truth show and not necessarily those of all particular listeners, particularly those listening, by simulcast on Brenda Johnson's program.

Brenda Johnson will then deliver her rebuttal of up to 5 minutes.

Following her rebuttal, Brenda Johnson will be allowed to present the first of her 4 questions to John Benko. John Benko will be afforded up to 2 minutes to respond. Brenda will be offered the option of a single rebuttal of up to 1 minute.

John Benko will then ask his question, in like manner, and the two will go back and forth until all 8 questions have been asked and answered.

*Commercial break* The views expressed in our commercial breaks reflect the views of the Deeper Truth show and not necessarily those of all particular listeners, particularly those listening, by simulcast on Brenda Johnson's program.

Brenda Johnson will be given up to 5 minutes to deliver closing remarks.

John Benko will follow.

If there are callers, or questions or comments posted in the chat room, Donald will begin presenting them. Each side will be able to respond to each question or comment, starting with the person addressed by the question or comment. If no one is specifically addressed, Brenda will always go first.

Each caller or commenter is limited to one question and then will be immediately dropped so we can keep the process moving. Callers who engage in ad homs, abusive tactics, scatter gun, filibustering or other such tactics will be dropped. The two contestants will agree when the show has gone on long enough. We hope you will tune in and offer your comment or question.




















Home page
DTB facebook Page
You Tube
Blog Talk Radio Show

Tuesday, October 1, 2013

Thank you for another record month

Deepertruthblog recorded more than 133,000 hits in the month of September. We appreciate your continued support.






Home page
DTB facebook Page
You Tube
Blog Talk Radio Show

Counting down the hours

Well, there will be a few last minute notes and quotes thrown in my satchel and put on my horse before I start my ride to the O.K. Corral, so to speak. The showdown is basically set and I am just fine tuning at this point. I have had my share of fun with the hyperbole and the visual imagery. While I certainly would think of myself as a gun-slinger in the mold of Clint Eastwood in the Outlaw Josey Wales here, I am sure my opponent wishes to fancy herself as a type of Sharon Stone's character in the classic (and appropriately Biblically titled) The Quick and the Dead. (I actually number both movies among my all-time favorites).

Sure, these images are fun and stir up the backers on either side of this classic, approaching encounter.  I think it is important to allow a little levity into this very serious matter. That is, so long as we do not lose sight of the fact that it is a very serious matter.

Sola Scriptura is a very serious and destructive heresy- maybe the most serious and most destructive because it is so cleverly disguised by the father-of-lies as an orthodox and foundational Christian precept. Sola Scriptura does not uphold Sacred Scripture, it trivializes it. Rather than Scripture being what it truly is, it becomes whatever I want it to be. Through the years, I have seen people take some of the most incredible liberties with Sacred Scripture, from using Luke 14:26 to demonstrate that Jesus hated His own mother to using Matthew 15:3 to demonstrate that Jesus was angry with the Pharisees because they didn't kill their own children.

Margaret Sangor used Scripture to justify abortion, and, through the years people have used it to argue for and against just about every idea or notion that man can conceive. The Devil, himself quoted scripture in the wilderness.

Two things that have been irrefutably proven about Scripture are;
  1. There is not a thought depraved enough that man cannot find and twist Scripture in a manner that will seem, to at least someone, to support it.
  2. Man, over the centuries, has exhausted this practice to radical excess.
Sola Scriptura is nonsense and denying it is not to deny Scripture to the Sheep....but to the wolves.






Home page
DTB facebook Page
You Tube
Blog Talk Radio Show

The Catholic Defender: Living The Blessing

Many times being deployed in the field, in the United States or placed over seas, it is popular to say we are "living the legend".

Sometimes we might say, "living the dream" when we are in the middle of taking on high stress situations. Well, sometimes it is even better to know that we are "living the blessing"!

How many times have you heard someone bless you or friends in a casual manner? Importantly, we leave Mass receiving a blessing to go into the world taking that blessing we have recieved into the world.

The blessing at the end of Mass is called "Invocative Blessing". This is the same blessing you recieve when a Priest blesses your home or visits the sick in the hospital. That is an invocative blessing. The Priest invokes (Latin voco) which simply means to call upon the Lord. It is a calling upon the Lord to bless those whom the Priest is blessing. An example of a blessing from a Priest would be, "May the blessing of God come down upon you and remain with you forever. Amen".

There is nothing magical or superstitious about blessings . God is the One who does the blessing. One blessing is for people and the other is for things, such as rosaries, bibles, medals, and similar items.

The blessing for people is called an Invocative Blessing and the blessing for things is called a Constitutive Blessing.

Examples of the Constitutive Blessing are religious medals. Constitutive blessings are blessings for things, the word constitutive is taken from the Latin verb "constituo". This means to determine or to make known. Blessings recieved through praying the rosary, using holy medals such as the Miraculas Medal, reading the bible are seen as sacred.

Objects of blessings represent the prayers of the Saints.

Acts 19:11-12 states, "God did extraordinary miracles through Paul, so that even handkerchiefs and aprons that had touched him were taken to the sick, and their illnesses were cured and the evil spirits left them."

An example of a blessing offered by the Priest for a bible: "Almighty God, we ask your blessing upon this bible. May it be a source of learning and blessing for all those who read it. We ask this through our Christ our Lord. Amen".

Blessing of homes, here is an example of a blessing: "Almighty God, we ask your blessing upon this home. Bless it and protect it from all trouble such as fire, storms and floods, and may the peace of your Son, Christ, be in this home and in the hearts of those living here."

Blessings are either spiritual or physical, they can be offered by clergy and laity, though they are different. When you are blessed by a Priest, this carries weight as we have seen with St. Paul. When a lay person is blessing someone, it falls in as a "Sacramental". The blessing of someone is creating a change.

Still, to receive a blessing it is important to know where the source is coming from. A blessing can actually be a curse becase the evil one has no power to offer a blessing. It is very common to ask for prayer from people, even if they are not Catholic.

A Grandmother who might be a Protestant, can you ask them to pray for you? This is an important question. Can we respect cultures that are not Christian giving a blessing from their heart?

I think that the Catholic Church would say that you can receive a blessing from someone with good intentions. This is at a different level that the Priest offering the blessings at Mass or any of the Sacraments. A non-Catholic cannot ordinarily recieve the Eucharist, but they can recieve a blessing from the person offering the Eucharist.

What makes a blessing from a Catholic Priest or any Catholic different from other Christians, from other religions? I believe there is a sharp distinction between Catholics and anyone else. St. Francis once noted that if he had an angel to his right and a Catholic priest to his left, he would first recognize the Priest because it is his right hand of blessing that offers Jesus Christ in the Eucharist.

As Catholics, this is kind of built into us so as to respect our Priests as holy men serving God. Even Priests who have done wrong, the Virgin Mary said at Fatima that we should never judge a Priest because they will have a severe judgment from Jesus if they are scandalous. We should pray for our Priests.

Sometimes it might be a blessing to suffer, what ever helps us grow in our faith, we can see the hand of God throughout our lives. Sometimes, we might not know it until you look back and see how the Lord has had his hand in your life.

I do believe that if we are living in God's grace, we are blessed. By bringing Christ to the world by our witness, like Mary, we become a blessed person. Living the life of the Sacraments, we are living the blessing.

So, next time someone asks you how you are doing, just tell them, "I'm living the blessing"!


Home page
DTB facebook Page
You Tube
Blog Talk Radio Show

Monday, September 30, 2013

Ready for battle, soberly aware of the stakes

     Sure, there has been some good-natured ribbing between myself and Brenda Johnson on Thursday's upcoming debate. Yes, it is also true that there is a certain level of pride in wanting to keep our win streak (now at 20) intact.

     I do find myself consciously trying to push that pride down and focus on what is really at stake because it is no small thing. As I often find myself amazed at the level of my own weakness, I should not be. That again, is that stubborn pride within me that I must fight to vanquish, with the help of God's Grace.

     That I need God desperately and that my soul cries out for Him is not a matter in dispute. It is quite plain, it is quite evident, it is quite uncontested. I know very well how sinful and weak I can be and I certainly don't need anyone to point it out to me. This is to say that I am a Christian- one who loves, worships, adores and desperately needs Jesus Christ.

     I doubt Brenda, if asked, would deny that she needs Jesus as desperately as I do. I also, do not doubt that she desires to follow Him every bit as much. The difference is how we find Him.

     Do we find Him at the christmas tree or at the tree of the cross? Is He found in the green pastures or the storm? Do we find Him in our joys or in our sorrows, in our triumphs or in our tragedies? Is His grace showered on us at once or given to us drop by drop like an IV?

     I believe some people spend too much time looking for Him in the wrong places or, at least, in the right places at the wrong times. If you haven't got the Jesus of the gospels right, how can you hope to get the Jesus of the end-times right?

     Thursday's debate is so critical because it goes to the heart of who Jesus is and what His church looks like. Sola Scriptura makes us orphans, left to try and find our way, as best we can, with nothing but a book we can't understand to guide us. I know that Jesus did not mean for it to be that way. He left us a church to be His hands and feet- to comfort, to minister to us, to guide us. He left His Holy Spirit to lead us through that church, not against it.

     This debate is about helping people find Christ, where He is- in His church. Jesus gave us His Scripture, yes. He gave us His Sacraments and His ministry as well. His church is the true path to heaven, His infallible Scripture, in her care.






Home page
DTB facebook Page
You Tube
Blog Talk Radio Show

Sunday, September 29, 2013

It's on!


To say that we are anxious to get this debate on would be a huge understatement. Listen live!

The show starts at 7:00 PM Eastern time. The call-in number is (646) 595-2071. Donald Hartley will run the switchboard/soundboard and Mr. Kohl Nelson will be our moderator. Please post this everywhere!




Home page
DTB facebook Page
You Tube
Blog Talk Radio Show

Friday, September 27, 2013

The Catholic Defender: Lady Of The Valley

My Brother David was a veteran of the Viet Nam War and he really did not survive it.

Like many other Vets, David did come home but because of the climate of the times, many Viet Nam Veterans never fully integrated back to the States.

According to John Draper, the project director of the "National Suicide Prevention Lifeline" states that Viet Nam Veterans are the highest of any particular group.


When David would go into town, he was always messed with by the local Sheriffs department. When they saw his car they always searched him.

On one occasion, knowing that he was going into town, he found a black snake living in one of our sycamore trees and he placed it in the trunk knowing they were going to stop him. 

Sure enough, they did and when they found the snake, that earned him a flash light across the back of the head.  He felt that he had at least some satisfaction that he earned that one.

David enrolled in a local bible college thinking he could get himself set on a right path, but that did not last long.  This was one of the hardest things my Mother had to endure watching one of her Son's enduring much pain just to live.

David eventually pulled up stakes and traveled west to Kansas for a little while, but he would end up in Seattle Washington where he began working at a hospital working with physical therapy.

It seemed like a couple of years went by, I was in college myself with a baseball scholarship when the Chaplain called me to his office.  It was then that I found out David was killed.  The Chaplain didn't know how at the time, but I spent some time in the chapel and made plans to go home to help my Mother.

Remembering this has been very difficult, I recently rediscovered a song that helped me cope with the loss.  It is from a group called White Lion, the song called "Lady of the Valley".  The words just fit perfectly with my emotions.

The words of the song:


Lyrics to Lady Of The Valley :



lady of the valley
can you hear me cry
in the sillness of the night
I have lost my brother
in the fights of the war
and my heart has broken down

in the night I cry but no one seems to hear
I step into the light but all I feel is fear

lady of the valley
can you bring him back
to the days when we were kids
once we were together
we stood young and strong
now it seems so long ago

the golden key is at the end of the chain
how it hurts ohh lady free me from this pain

in the night I cry to the lady of the valley
cause I'll die without the lady of the valley
in the night I call to the lady of the valley
on my knees I fall before the lady of the valley

in the valley lies the treasure
and the lady guards it well
he who bears all the pressure
is the one to break the spell
there's a sign that I've followed
and it has led me to your seat
I have brought my fallen brother
and I've laid him, yes I've laid him
at your feet

in the night I cry to the lady of the valley
cause I'll die without the lady of the valley
in the night I call to the lady of the valley
on my knees I fall before the lady of the valley
This life is but a journey, we are pilgrims in a strange land.  We have a God who truly loves us.  Jesus is our King, and from the cross he gives us His Mother that we can place our pain before Our Lady of the Valley.



Home page
DTB facebook Page
You Tube
Blog Talk Radio Show

Thursday, September 26, 2013

The Catholic Defender: Stand For Life

Folks, it is that time of year when people will put on their marching shoes and go pray at the Abortion facilities.

This is good because "40 Days For Life" has done a lot of good to get people to think about what abortion is.

It feels good when you have people out there all day long to stand for life.

I see people out with their rosaries and prayer books to pray and meditate.

This is American freedom to be able to assemble and take a stand for life.

Our Priest spoke of how important it was for him to have gone out there on the front line.

I think it is even more important for him to go there for the sake of the people out there.

This particular lazy day, I had the opportunity to come out to the Abortion Clinic in Killeen Texas where I prayed the Rosary and the Divine Mercy.

This day was a slow day, there was only two of us out there but I felt it mattered not.

I positioned myself with my cross and stood up where I was most visible to those driving by.

What a great feeling it is to get people honking their horns giving you the thumbs up sign and waving towards you.

That is a great encouragement. Often I will have people stop and pray with me because they are affected by our witness.

That means a lot! This day, one person stopped to thank me for taking a stand for life.

He wanted to share his story with me and I was eager to listen as I waved on to the traffic passing by.

Another Lady parked in the parking lot behind me and was taking pictures of me.

I didn't know she was there initially, but I had that feeling that someone was watching me from the back so I stopped and turned around and there she was.

She then got out of her car and brought her camera wanting to take some pictures.

She was Norwegian traveling the United States and was simply driving by and saw me with the cross.

This Lady actually took these pictures I have for this article! I encouraged her to be safe and enjoy her traveling our Country.

One of my Daughter-In-Laws (Szilvia) is leaving the United States today for Hungary.

Her Mother is in the Hospital and it is important for her to go home and see her Mother.

My wife Gigi is still watching the grandchildren in Washington State so I am still on my own for another couple of weeks.

Another lady came by with her son and saw me and then stopped to tell me her story.

She told me the sad truth that she had two abortions when she was younger. That is still affected her deeply.

I was able to encourage her and was glad that she stopped to talk to me. She told me how important her faith was to her.

This is very important, in fact, a most important message of 40 Days for Life.

That a woman needs that healing for inner peace. That Jesus will forgive her.

That is the mission of the Church, to liberate the captives and set them free in Christ.

Even on a lazy day, you can still get a lot of things done just by being available!


Home page
DTB facebook Page
You Tube
Blog Talk Radio Show

The Catholic Defender: The Signers of The Declaration of Independance

The following is taken from Rush Limbaugh, I was so touched by this I wanted to share this with our readers.

Rush first shared that Senator Ted Cruz read this story during his 21 hour siege on the Senate floor.

If I am not mistaken, Rush originally states that his father wrote this story based on a work he did on this subject.

I was in the Army for more than 26 years and the Constitution has always been important to me.  Our freedoms are important to me.  Holding on to those freedoms are important to me.

The following is the writing shared by Rush Limbaugh:

 The Americans Who Risked Everything 

My father, Rush H. Limbaugh, Jr., delivered this oft-requested address locally a number of times, but it had never before appeared in print until it appeared in The Limbaugh Letter. My dad was renowned for his oratory skills and for his original mind; this speech is, I think, a superb demonstration of both. I will always be grateful to him for instilling in me a passion for the ideas and lives of America's Founders, as well as a deep appreciation for the inspirational power of words which you will see evidenced here:

Our Lives, Our Fortunes, 

Our Sacred Honor

Rush H. Limbaugh, Jr.
It was a glorious morning. The sun was shining and the wind was from the southeast. Up especially early, a tall bony, redheaded young Virginian found time to buy a new thermometer, for which he paid three pounds, fifteen shillings. He also bought gloves for Martha, his wife, who was ill at home.
Thomas Jefferson arrived early at the statehouse. The temperature was 72.5 degrees and the horseflies weren't nearly so bad at that hour. It was a lovely room, very large, with gleaming white walls. The chairs were comfortable. Facing the single door were two brass fireplaces, but they would not be used today.

The moment the door was shut, and it was always kept locked, the room became an oven. The tall windows were shut, so that loud quarreling voices could not be heard by passersby. Small openings atop the windows allowed a slight stir of air, and also a large number of horseflies. Jefferson records that "the horseflies were dexterous in finding necks, and the silk of stocking was nothing to them." All discussion was punctuated by the slap of hands on necks.

On the wall at the back, facing the President's desk, was a panoply-consisting of a drum, swords, and banners seized from Fort Ticonderoga the previous year. Ethan Allen and Benedict Arnold had captured the place, shouting that they were taking it "in the name of the Great Jehovah and the Continental Congress!"

Now Congress got to work, promptly taking up an emergency measure about which there was discussion but no dissention. "Resolved: That an application be made to the Committee of Safety of Pennsylvania for a supply of flints for the troops at New York." 

Then Congress transformed itself into a committee of the whole. The Declaration of Independence was read aloud once more, and debate resumed. Though Jefferson was the best writer of all of them, he had been somewhat verbose. Congress hacked the excess away. They did a good job, as a side-by-side comparison of the rough draft and the final text shows. They cut the phrase "by a self-assumed power." "Climb" was replaced by "must read," then "must" was eliminated, then the whole sentence, and soon the whole paragraph was cut. Jefferson groaned as they continued what he later called "their depredations." "Inherent and inalienable rights" came out "certain unalienable rights," and to this day no one knows who suggested the elegant change.

A total of 86 alterations were made. Almost 500 words were eliminated, leaving 1,337. At last, after three days of wrangling, the document was put to a vote.

Here in this hall Patrick Henry had once thundered: " I am no longer a Virginian, Sir, but an American." But today the loud, sometimes bitter argument stilled, and without fanfare the vote was taken from north to south by colonies, as was the custom. On July 4, 1776, the Declaration of Independence was adopted.

There were no trumpets blown. No one stood on his chair and cheered. The afternoon was waning and Congress had no thought of delaying the full calendar of routine business on its hands. For several hours they worked on many other problems before adjourning for the day.

Much To Lose

What kind of men were the 56 signers who adopted the Declaration of Independence and who, by their signing, committed an act of treason against the crown? To each of you the names Franklin, Adams, Hancock, and Jefferson are almost as familiar as household words. Most of us, however, know nothing of the other signers. Who were they? What happened to them?

I imagine that many of you are somewhat surprised at the names not there: George Washington, Alexander Hamilton, Patrick Henry. All were elsewhere.

Ben Franklin was the only really old man. Eighteen were under 40; three were in their 20s. Of the 56 almost half -24- were judges and lawyers. Eleven were merchants, 9 were landowners and farmers, and the remaining 12 were doctors, ministers, and politicians.

With only a few exceptions, such as Samuel Adams of Massachusetts, these were men of substantial property. All but two had families. The vast majority were men of education and standing in their communities. They had economic security as few men had in the 18th century. 

Each had more to lose from revolution than he had to gain by it. John Hancock, one of the richest men in America, already had a price of 500 pounds on his head. He signed in enormous letters so "that his Majesty could now read his name without glasses and could now double the reward." Ben Franklin wryly noted: "Indeed we must all hang together, otherwise we shall most assuredly hang separately." Fat Benjamin Harrison of Virginia told tiny Elbridge Gerry of Massachusetts: "With me it will all be over in a minute, but you , you will be dancing on air an hour after I am gone.

These men knew what they risked. The penalty for treason was death by hanging. And remember: a great British fleet was already at anchor in New York Harbor.

They were sober men. There were no dreamy-eyed intellectuals or draft card burners here. They were far from hot-eyed fanatics, yammering for an explosion. They simply asked for the status quo. It was change they resisted. It was equality with the mother country they desired. It was taxation with representation they sought. They were all conservatives, yet they rebelled.

It was principle, not property, that had brought these men to Philadelphia. Two of them became presidents of the United States. Seven of them became state governors. One died in office as vice president of the United States. Several would go on to be U.S. Senators. One, the richest man in America, in 1828 founded the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad. One, a delegate from Philadelphia, was the only real poet, musician and philosopher of the signers (it was he, Francis Hopkinson - not Betsy Ross who designed the United States flag).

Richard Henry Lee, A delegate from Virginia, had introduced the resolution to adopt the Declaration of Independence in June of 1776. He was prophetic in his concluding remarks:

"Why then sir, why do we longer delay? Why still deliberate? Let this happy day give birth to an American Republic. Let her arise not to devastate and to conquer but to reestablish the reign of peace and law. The eyes of Europe are fixed upon us. She demands of us a living example of freedom that may exhibit a contrast in the felicity of the citizen to the ever increasing tyranny which desolates her polluted shores. She invites us to prepare an asylum where the unhappy may find solace, and the persecuted repost. If we are not this day wanting in our duty, the names of the American Legislatures of 1776 will be placed by posterity at the side of all of those whose memory has been and ever will be dear to virtuous men and good citizens." 

Though the resolution was formally adopted July 4, it was not until July 8 that two of the states authorized their delegates to sign, and it was not until August 2 that the signers met at Philadelphia to actually put their names to the Declaration.

William Ellery, delegate from Rhode Island, was curious to see the signers' faces as they committed this supreme act of personal courage. He saw some men sign quickly, "but in no face was he able to discern real fear." Stephan Hopkins, Ellery's colleague from Rhode Island, was a man past 60. As he signed with a shaking pen, he declared: "My hand trembles, but my heart does not."

"Most glorious service"

Even before the list was published, the British marked down every member of Congress suspected of having put his name to treason. All of them became the objects of vicious manhunts. Some were taken. Some, like Jefferson, had narrow escapes. All who had property or families near British strongholds suffered.

- Francis Lewis, New York delegate saw his home plundered and his estates in what is now Harlem, completely destroyed by British soldiers. Mrs. Lewis was captured and treated with great brutality. Though she was later exchanged for two British prisoners through the efforts of Congress, she died from the effects of her abuse.

- William Floyd, another New York delegate, was able to escape with his wife and children across Long Island Sound to Connecticut, where they lived as refugees without income for seven years. When they came home they found a devastated ruin.

- Philips Livingstone had all his great holdings in New York confiscated and his family driven out of their home. Livingstone died in 1778 still working in Congress for the cause.
- Louis Morris, the fourth New York delegate, saw all his timber, crops, and livestock taken. For seven years he was barred from his home and family.

John Hart of Trenton, New Jersey, risked his life to return home to see his dying wife. Hessian soldiers rode after him, and he escaped in the woods. While his wife lay on her deathbed, the soldiers ruined his farm and wrecked his homestead. Hart, 65, slept in caves and woods as he was hunted across the countryside. When at long last, emaciated by hardship, he was able to sneak home, he found his wife had already been buried, and his 13 children taken away. He never saw them again. He died a broken man in 1779, without ever finding his family.

- Dr. John Witherspoon, signer, was president of the College of New Jersey, later called Princeton. The British occupied the town of Princeton, and billeted troops in the college. They trampled and burned the finest college library in the country. 

- Judge Richard Stockton, another New Jersey delegate signer, had rushed back to his estate in an effort to evacuate his wife and children. The family found refuge with friends, but a Tory sympathizer betrayed them. Judge Stockton was pulled from bed in the night and brutally beaten by the arresting soldiers. Thrown into a common jail, he was deliberately starved. Congress finally arranged for Stockton's parole, but his health was ruined. The judge was released as an invalid, when he could no longer harm the British cause. He returned home to find his estate looted and did not live to see the triumph of the revolution. His family was forced to live off charity. 

- Robert Morris, merchant prince of Philadelphia, delegate and signer, met Washington's appeals and pleas for money year after year. He made and raised arms and provisions which made it possible for Washington to cross the Delaware at Trenton. In the process he lost 150 ships at sea, bleeding his own fortune and credit almost dry. 

George Clymer, Pennsylvania signer, escaped with his family from their home, but their property was completely destroyed by the British in the Germantown and Brandywine campaigns.
- Dr. Benjamin Rush, also from Pennsylvania, was forced to flee to Maryland. As a heroic surgeon with the army, Rush had several narrow escapes. 

 John Martin, a Tory in his views previous to the debate, lived in a strongly loyalist area of Pennsylvania. When he came out for independence, most of his neighbors and even some of his relatives ostracized him. He was a sensitive and troubled man, and many believed this action killed him. When he died in 1777, his last words to his tormentors were: "Tell them that they will live to see the hour when they shall acknowledge it [the signing] to have been the most glorious service that I have ever rendered to my country." 

- William Ellery, Rhode Island delegate, saw his property and home burned to the ground.
- Thomas Lynch, Jr., South Carolina delegate, had his health broken from privation and exposures while serving as a company commander in the military. His doctors ordered him to seek a cure in the West Indies and on the voyage he and his young bride were drowned at sea. 

- Edward Rutledge, Arthur Middleton, and Thomas Heyward, Jr., the other three South Carolina signers, were taken by the British in the siege of Charleston. They were carried as prisoners of war to St. Augustine, Florida, where they were singled out for indignities. They were exchanged at the end of the war, the British in the meantime having completely devastated their large landholdings and estates. 

- Thomas Nelson, signer of Virginia, was at the front in command of the Virginia military forces. With British General Charles Cornwallis in Yorktown, fire from 70 heavy American guns began to destroy Yorktown piece by piece. Lord Cornwallis and his staff moved their headquarters into Nelson's palatial home. While American cannonballs were making a shambles of the town, the house of Governor Nelson remained untouched. Nelson turned in rage to the American gunners and asked, "Why do you spare my home?" They replied, "Sir, out of respect to you." Nelson cried, "Give me the cannon!" and fired on his magnificent home himself, smashing it to bits. But Nelson's sacrifice was not quite over. He had raised $2 million for the Revolutionary cause by pledging his own estates. When the loans came due, a newer peacetime Congress refused to honor them, and Nelson's property was forfeited. He was never reimbursed. He died, impoverished, a few years later at the age of 50.
Lives, fortunes, honor Of those 56 who signed the Declaration of Independence, nine died of wounds or hardships during the war. Five were captured and imprisoned, in each case with brutal treatment. Several lost wives, sons or entire families. One lost his 13 children. Two wives were brutally treated. All were at one time or another the victims of manhunts and driven from their homes. Twelve signers had their homes completely burned. Seventeen lost everything they owned. Yet not one defected or went back on his pledged word. Their honor, and the nation they sacrificed so much to create is still intact.

And, finally, there is the New Jersey Signer, Abraham Clark.
He gave two sons to the officer corps in the Revolutionary Army. They were captured and sent to that infamous British prison hulk afloat in New York Harbor known as the hell ship "Jersey," where 11,000 American captives were to die. The younger Clarks were treated with a special brutality because of their father. One was put in solitary and given no food. With the end almost in sight with the war almost won, no one could have blamed Abraham Clark for acceding to the British request when they offered him his sons' lives if he would recant and come out for the King and Parliament. The utter despair in this man's heart, the anguish in his very soul, must reach out to each and every one of us down through 200 years with the answer: "No." 

The 56 signers of the Declaration of Independence proved by their every deed that they made no idle boast when they composed the most magnificent curtain line in history. "And for the support of this Declaration with a firm reliance on the protection of divine providence, we mutually pledge to each other our lives, our fortunes, and our sacred honor."






Home page
DTB facebook Page
You Tube
Blog Talk Radio Show